🥇 #1 Winner · October 2026

Bear River Mutual Insurance - Keystone Insurance Services

Best Insurance Agency in Payson

Good · 78/100 4.6★ · 17 Google reviews Monthly Index 85.3
Bear River Mutual Insurance - Keystone Insurance Services: TrailBlaze Utah Best Insurance Agency in Payson, October 2026 TRAILBLAZE UTAH OFFICIAL WINNER BEAR RIVER MUTUAL INSURANCE BEST INSURANCE AGENCY IN PAYSON, UTAH OCTOBER 2026

Why Bear River Mutual Insurance - Keystone Insurance Services won

Scored 78/100 (Good) on TrailBlaze's independent check of public information, with a 4.6★ Google rating across 17 reviews. Started showing up in Google search on TrailBlaze: 111 showings in October, up from 10 in September. Ranked #1 of 3 qualifying businesses in its category and city.

Customer activity (40% of the index) 86/100

No customer activity on TrailBlaze in October

Digital health (40% of the index) 78/100

TrailBlaze Score 78/100 (Good), from public information only

Momentum (20% of the index) 100/100

111 search showings (10 in September)

Monthly Index = 40% activity + 40% digital health + 20% momentum. 3 of 3 insurance agency businesses in Payson qualified this month. Payment counts 0%. How winners are picked · Full score report

🏆 October Winner — is this your business?

Congratulations on winning Best Insurance Agency in Payson for October 2026!

Claim your profile free to get your official winner badge for your website, manage your listing, see your full score report, and see every call and lead TrailBlaze sends you. It takes about a minute: we send a code to the phone or email already on your listing.

Claim this profile free

Share this award

Best Insurance Agency in Payson: October 2026 top 3

  1. #1 Bear River Mutual Insurance - Keystone Insurance Services 85.3
  2. #2 Utah Avenue Insurance (Payson) 75.3
  3. #3 The Insurance Center of Utah LLC 70.3
See all 3 insurance agency businesses in Payson →

← All October 2026 winners